CarCheckHQ
Check a car

Guide

Selling your car privately: how to spot a fake buyer and get paid safely

Keep the car, the keys and the log book until the full amount has cleared in your own bank account. A screenshot, email or text from the buyer isn't payment. If someone overpays and wants the difference back, or rushes you, stop.

Published by CarCheckHQ · Updated . Written by the CarCheckHQ team.

Most buyers are genuine. This guide covers the tricks the others use, and the simple habits that stop them.

The one rule that stops most payment tricks

Money first, car second.

Check your own banking app, or call your bank yourself. British Transport Police tells online sellers to check their account or ask their bank to make sure cleared funds have arrived.

Nothing the buyer shows you on their phone counts. Only your own account does.

Fake payment proof: screenshots, emails and texts

Screenshots can be edited. British Transport Police warns that fake buyers send spoof emails as proof of payment, and then the money never turns up.

So log in to your bank yourself. Don't use a link or phone number from the buyer's message, even if it looks like it came from your bank.

Overpayments and "send me back the difference"

Here's how it goes. A buyer pays more than your price, then asks you to send the extra back.

Don't send anything. Ask them to cancel the payment and pay the right amount instead. Citizens Advice lists being asked to move money quickly as a sign of a scam.

If the overpayment came by cheque, West Yorkshire Police is clear: never let the car go until the cheque has cleared.

Cash, cheques and banker's drafts

Each way of being paid needs a different check. In short:

How you're paidWhat to checkWhen to hand over
Bank transferThe full amount shows as cleared in your own account. Check it yourself, not from a screenshot.Once the full amount has cleared
CashCount it all and look out for fakes. Bank it as soon as you can.Once it's counted, ideally at your bank
ChequeWait for it to clear through your account.Only after it has cleared
Banker's draftForgeries exist, so treat it like a cheque.Only after the money has cleared

West Yorkshire Police suggests doing a cash swap at your bank, where the cashier can spot forgeries and you can pay it straight in.

Advice on cash isn't the same everywhere. Warwickshire Trading Standards says not to accept cash at all, and to take a bank transfer only. Whichever you choose, the car stays with you until the money is yours.

Viewings and test drives

Show the car at home or in a busy place you know well. Have a second adult with you if you can, so someone can keep an eye on things if you get distracted.

Before a test drive, check the buyer is insured to drive your car. Never let them go out alone. And never leave the keys in the ignition when you swap seats.

We'd also keep the spare key indoors. The other steps here come from West Yorkshire Police and Warwickshire Trading Standards.

The sudden "engine fault" trick

In July 2026, Warwickshire Trading Standards warned about groups of fake buyers working together. One distracts the seller while another opens the bonnet and tampers with the wiring or pours oil in. Then they claim the car has a serious fault and push the price down.

What to do:

  • Stay with the car the whole time.
  • Don't leave anyone alone at the open bonnet.
  • If anything feels off, walk away.

Pressure signs: when to walk away

Take Five to Stop Fraud says only criminals will try to rush or panic you, and it's fine to refuse. Citizens Advice lists being asked to move money quickly as a sign of a scam.

We'd treat these as warning signs too:

  • They rush you to hand over the car.
  • They want you to pay a fee or buy something before they'll pay.
  • They offer more than your asking price without seeing the car.
  • They push to move the chat off the selling platform.

One version of this has its own guide: a buyer asked me to buy a vehicle check from their link.

Handing over safely, in order

  1. Check the money. It shows as cleared in your own account, and you've checked it yourself.
  2. Write a receipt. West Yorkshire Police suggests writing one for both of you. We'd put the date, the price, both names and addresses, the registration and the mileage on it.
  3. Hand over. Give the buyer the keys and the green new keeper slip from the log book.
  4. Tell DVLA. Use the GOV.UK service to tell DVLA you've sold the car. Your vehicle tax is then cancelled, and you get a refund for any full months left.

For what the log book does and doesn't prove, see our guide on whether a V5C proves ownership.

If you've been caught out

Call your bank straight away, using the number on your card. If someone calls you claiming to be your bank, hang up and call 159.

Then report it:

  • England and Wales: report it to Report Fraud online or on 0300 123 2040.
  • Scotland: report it to Police Scotland.
  • Scam texts and emails: forward texts to 7726 and emails to report@phishing.gov.uk.

Tell the selling platform too, using its report tool. To reach Trading Standards, call the Citizens Advice consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133.

Questions sellers ask

Is a bank transfer safe when selling a car?

It's the method Warwickshire Trading Standards recommends, as long as the full amount shows as cleared in your own account. Check it yourself, not from a screenshot.

Should I let a buyer test drive my car alone?

No. Go with them, and check they're insured first.

When should I hand over the log book?

After the money has cleared. Give them the green new keeper slip and tell DVLA online.

What if a buyer wants me to buy a car check from their link?

Don't. Our separate guide on buyers who ask you to buy a vehicle check covers it.

What this guide can't tell you

This is general safety advice for private sellers in the UK, not legal or financial advice. We can't tell you whether a particular buyer is genuine.

Advice on cash differs between police forces and Trading Standards. Reporting routes change, so check the sources below before you rely on a number.

Sources

All checked on 26 October 2026.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. CarCheckHQ is independent and isn't linked to DVLA, the police or any bank.